As a Florida homeowner, you're likely aware of the state's increasingly volatile insurance market. With multiple carriers exiting the market or drastically increasing premiums, many homeowners are left with limited options. Some insurance companies have even stopped writing new policies in Florida altogether, leaving homeowners to navigate a complex and often expensive situation.
Based on federal consumer protection law and HUD/CFPB public guidance · Last reviewed July 2026
The Direct Answer
If your homeowner's insurance policy has been dropped, you're not alone: in 2022, over 400,000 Florida policies were non-renewed by insurance carriers. This drastic shift in the market leaves many homeowners scrambling to find new, affordable coverage.
While some carriers still offer policies in Florida, rates have skyrocketed, with the average annual premium exceeding $2,500 in some areas. Homeowners must carefully weigh their options, considering factors like coverage limits, deductibles, and premium costs when selecting a new policy.
Do not assume you can simply switch to a new carrier without reviewing your policy terms: some insurers may offer lower premiums but with significantly reduced coverage, leaving you vulnerable to financial losses in the event of a claim.
Understanding the Florida Insurance Market
Carrier Exodus
Multiple insurance carriers have exited the Florida market in recent years, citing increased risk and financial losses due to hurricanes and other natural disasters. This reduction in competition has led to higher premiums and reduced options for homeowners. For example, a homeowner in Miami-Dade County may pay upwards of $3,000 annually for a policy with a $1,000 deductible and $250,000 in coverage.
Exploring Alternative Options
Citizens Property Insurance
As a state-run insurance provider, Citizens Property Insurance offers coverage to Florida homeowners who are unable to secure private insurance. However, premiums can be higher than those offered by private carriers, and coverage limits may be lower. Homeowners should carefully review the terms and conditions of a Citizens policy before enrolling.
Mitigating Risks and Costs
Homeowners can take steps to mitigate the risks and costs associated with the volatile insurance market. Regularly reviewing and updating your policy can help ensure you have adequate coverage, while implementing storm-resistant features can help reduce your premium costs. Additionally, shopping around and comparing rates from multiple carriers can help you secure the best possible rate for your needs.
Find Affordable Insurance Options
Don't settle for inadequate coverage or exorbitant premiums. Research and compare insurance options to find the best fit for your needs and budget.
Why are insurance carriers exiting the Florida market?
Insurance carriers are exiting the Florida market due to increased risk and financial losses resulting from hurricanes and other natural disasters. This has led to a reduction in competition, resulting in higher premiums and reduced options for homeowners.
Can I switch to a new insurance carrier if my policy is non-renewed?
Yes, you can switch to a new insurance carrier if your policy is non-renewed. However, be sure to carefully review the terms and conditions of any new policy, including coverage limits, deductibles, and premium costs.
What is Citizens Property Insurance, and how does it work?
Citizens Property Insurance is a state-run insurance provider that offers coverage to Florida homeowners who are unable to secure private insurance. While premiums can be higher and coverage limits may be lower, it can provide a necessary safety net for those who cannot find alternative coverage.
How can I reduce my insurance premium costs?
You can reduce your insurance premium costs by implementing storm-resistant features, regularly reviewing and updating your policy, and shopping around to compare rates from multiple carriers. Additionally, considering a higher deductible or opting for a policy with a lower coverage limit may also help lower your premium costs.